There are two kinds of people; those we love and those we don't know.
Question #93167 posted on 06/09/2020 4:26 a.m.
Q:

Dear 100 Hour Board,

So I started dating a guy from Tinder.

I'm sure my grandma will be thrilled if I "settle down" with a returned missionary with a stable job who's good-looking. I think he would get along with my brother and sister, who are my closest friends. I'm glad to find someone smart and where I feel chemistry, who shares my values, and actually treats me well.

I am, however, contemplating the identity shift involved with getting into a fairly vanilla monogamous relationship with a dude from my hometown.

I have read a lot about marriage as an institution (channeling Mae West, have spent over 30 years trying not to get 5150ed), and it seems like it can be a vehicle for self-betterment and even self-expression for yuppies like ourselves. Frankly, I think that I would probably be happier in my day-to-day married than I have been single.

However, there are other moral and artistic considerations. I think I spent some of my early adulthood with bohemian affectations but a deeply conformist worldview. Now, I feel like I appear quite bourgeoise, but philosophically, I've become more radical.

I have a hard time thinking of that many suburban married white women who changed the world.

No surprise, my ultimate aim is to be a writer, and that's a super lucrative and stable profession. I really do have a deep-seated fear of becoming some guy's economic dependent, in whole or in part, and waking up one day saying to myself, "What happened to that woman who answered to no one? Am I just playing out a script because I couldn't think of anything more creative?"

I guess I don't even know how to start a dialogue with someone, especially without it becoming about my parents' marriage, which it's safe to say, is the opposite of what I want for myself.

The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there. If there's one thing you wish you knew before going down the path to the altar, what is it?

---Portia, living up to her namesake's ambivalence

A:

Dear Portia,

It's not a 100% identical situation, but your predicament sounds like how my partner was when we started dating. We're very different people, on a surface level. He's an atheist who never wanted to end up with a Mormon, let alone a BYU student. I'm almost neurotically religious. His bigger fear is living a meaningless life in "suburbia hell" and never reaching his potential. I'd probably be content to live in Northern Utah my whole life because it's where my family is and, to be honest, I'm a bit of a square.
 
Because we value similar things, when it comes down to it—we like to make each other laugh, our love languages are the same, we don't like seeing others hurt and want to help how we can—it works. We've both faced a little teasing from our friends and have questioned how it will work in the long run, and I felt pressured early in our relationship to date someone I could bring to the temple someday to try and "prove" that I was still worthy. Mostly because as a trans member, I felt that I had a lot to prove.
 
But we bring joy to each other's lives. To me, that's what matters, even if it will change how we expected both of our lives to turn out. And through our differences and many discussions about how we see the world and why, we've both grown and (at least on my end through him) become better people through it.
 
The advice I'd give is to consider what makes you happy versus what you feel expected to do or prove to others. If you can see yourself being genuinely happy and fulfilled with him, then does it matter whether it matches how you expected your life to turn out? I think there's an element to love that's about taking risks, and I also think that being in a relationship is bound to shift your identities/worldviews over time regardless of the situations. That seems to be what happens when you share emotional intimacy with another person. Maybe this is a risk worth taking, if this person brings joy to your life. 
 
-Van Goff
A:

Dear Portia (or rather, Jo March),  

Even as a married woman, you don't have to be a white vanilla suburban wife who answers to her husband. And if that's what this marriage would end up being, don't get married... at least not to him.

I may still be in the very early stages of my marriage, but I have a husband who actively supports me when I want to go to protests, listens and participates when I go on rails about political discussions until the early morning hours, and reminds me constantly how grateful he is that I speak my mind and am stubborn, opinionated, and independent. He doesn't feel like that's a threat to him at all, rather, he is inspired by me. 

I have a man that I love wholeheartedly. We get to cuddle every night and tackle life events together. He teaches me about my flaws and my talents, and in my 3 years of being in a relationship with him, I've changed a lot - for the better. 

You are right - marriage can be a vehicle for immense self-improvement, and I highly recommend it because I am *way* happier getting to do all the mundane life stuff with someone who makes me laugh all the time. There are "vanilla" aspects of everyone's life, but living life as a married woman isn't "vanilla" because everyone's life is different. Maybe he doesn't want a vanilla life either! A discussion about goals seems in order. 

When you make the right decision, even if your husband is the one working, he won't consider you a "dependent" and you shouldn't feel that way either... because you're a team. It's "our" money not "his" money that you "use." He'll support you in your goals of writing and wants you to succeed, and he'll be by your side. 

Does he respect your independence? Does he champion and cherish a strong woman who chases after her own dreams? 

None of these expectations are unrealistic at all, so if he meets them, you've got a keeper, and being married is awesome. 

Cheers, 

Guesthouse

A:

Dear Portia,

I think you should decide what you want from your life and live it. Is your goal to "change the world"? How do you want to change the world? Is being married going to hamper that goal? Ulrich's oft-cited quote of "well-behaved women seldom make history" was meant as a critique of history. Domestic labor is immensely valuable! So your typical suburbanite isn't going to be leading a rebellion or masterminding a great work of art. It doesn't matter where you live, most people don't "change the world," period. Or maybe we should be looking at this from another angle. Everyone changes the world. 

I've edited a LOT of Wikipedia pages in the last five years. Thousands of people read information that I researched every day. But is that change "better" than the love and care I give to my family? Whose life is going to be more changed by my actions, the person who reads something I wrote, or the child I spent every day talking to at dinner? Unless you have specific plans that require you to be single (like... joining a nunnery, or other specific volunteer organizations), I don't think that marriage should prevent you from doing what you want to. 

-Whistler

posted on 06/09/2020 10:15 a.m.
I highly, highly recommend seeing a therapist. I am a strong, independent woman who sees the world much like you do. Therapy has helped me understand my own believe systems, my values, what healthy boundaries look like for me in a relationship, and so much more! It has also helped me completely dismantle belief systems I didn't even know I had that were not serving me.

It sounds like you have some beliefs about dependence and some beliefs about marriage stemming from your parents. A therapist could help you work through these and ensure you have a world view that serves you and is not something you simply picked up along the way. And they could help you understand what kind of boundaries to maintain in a relationship to help you thrive as that person within a marriage.

For me, therapy is something I wish everyone had access to and believed in! I don't see it as just a means to address "problems" or "issues." It's a way to know yourself better. And the more you know yourself, including all your underlying belief systems, the better of you will be in all aspects of your life! Seriously, I cannot recommend it enough if you have the means!

Someone Who Loves My Therapy Sessions More Than Almost Anything Else!